Detuning High Voltage Lines in New York

The path was cleared for a new electricityembedding fiber optic cable in these wires has made
transmission line in New York that that could not bethese mechanical modifications quite a bit more
energized until interference problems with acomplicated.
Rensselaer, N.Y., AM radio station were resolved toTo evaluate and resolve the New York problem, an
the satisfaction of the New York Public Utilityengineering firm was called in by CH2M Hill, an
Commission.international consulting engineering firm based in
After extensive onsite and computer analysis,Colorado. The eight disruptive transmission structures
engineers determined that 8 of 33 tall power towerswere subsequently identified through field
on this line in the proximate area of stationmeasurements and software modeling. Their negative
WGDJ-AM would disrupt the stations licensedimpacts were remediated by an AM protection
coverage pattern and require installation of detuningdetuning process, allowing the project to proceed.
systems.The offending structures were detuned using
The transmission towers carry a 345 kV electricalcustom-engineered hardware along with modifications
power line from a 635-megawatt natural gas firedto the new power line. Modifications were carefully
power plant constructed in Rensselaer by Empiredesigned for safety and usability in conjunction with
Generation Co. LLC. The distribution system has 70CH2M Hill and the owners, and implemented by LG
towers in all, the last of which were erected lastConstructors. Necessarily, all detuning hardware was
summer. The question was how many of them nearconstructed, installed, and documented to rigorous
East Greenbush, N.Y., would cause signal interferenceutility standards.
with broadcasts of the AM station. The interferenceThe process has been employed hundreds of times
would have created a violation of FCC rulesto detune cellular industry towers with AM radio
governing the integrity of broadcast signals.interference problems of their own. While
Transmission towers often are a height that makestechnological applications vary in each case, they are
for efficient radiation of medium wave AM signals.rooted in the same family of engineered solutions.
The broadcast AM signal is intercepted from theThis was an important design consideration, as
environment by the power tower and "reradiated".renting transmission tower space to wireless carriers
This reradiated AM signal interferes with the designedis an important revenue source for utilities. In the
coverage and interference of the AM broadcastevent the detuned towers were to be rented to a
antenna system. The Federal Communicationscarrier to support their antennas, the AM dutuning
Commission licenses AM station antenna systems todocumentation would also support the carrier's FCC
very tight tolerances, and only a few percentAM protection requirements.
reradiated powerline signal can seriously impact theInteractions between high voltage transmission
licensed pattern performance.systems and AM stations are expected to grow in
The proper evaluation and remediation of power linefuture years. Thousands of miles of powerlines are
reradiation can be complex. The multiple transmissionplanned to support the smart grid, wind turbine, and
towers and the coupling between them throughphotovoltaic power generation. Many of these will
lightning shield wires can be a challenging analysis, butpass near AM broadcast antennas. It is vitally
also spread the impact much more broadly thanimportant for utility planners to have proposed routes
would a single tower. These interconnections formreviewed by an RF engineer early in that process. If
conductive loops which have vastly different electricallines can't be rerouted, then detuning can be
properties than single towers. Normally, a techniqueincorporated in the design process, at great savings
called "detuning" is applied, along with modifications ofover construction stage delays or modifications.
lightning shield wires. The recent practice of