Banking Industry - Politics of Punishment

The politics of punishment are tricky. Take theburgeoning balance sheets. Even as President Obama
playground, for example. The boy in the striped shirtdefends the necessity of the bailout in the first place,
not only pushed your child out of the way at the tophe has criticized the banking industry for proposing
of the slide, but also gives your child a good kick fornearly record-breaking bonuses. According to the
his efforts when he reaches the bottom. You canAssociated Press, "Six of the biggest U.S. banks are
comfort your own child, but you can't truly punish theon track to pay $150 billion in total executive
boy in the striped shirt; he is a stranger. You cancompensation for 2009, slightly less than the record
hope that his parents have a vigilant eye on the$164 billion in 2007 before the financial crisis struck,
playground and will step in and say something, butaccording to the New York state comptroller's
that doesn't always happen.office."
It's even trickier to punish adults who are actingThe President is strongly suggesting that banks pay
within legal parameters, if not moral ones. Presidentthe fee out of the bonus pool, rather than find ways
Obama would like to create a tax to punish banksto pass the cost of the fee down to the customer.
for effectively taking the bailout money and running.However, it is more likely that banks will keep the
He is calling it a fee, but the proposal is actually for abonuses and find ways around the tax. Some of
0.15 percent tax on the liabilities of large financialthose solutions could involve risky loans, which is
institutions. The tax only applies to companies withwhat started this whole mess in the first place.
assets of more than $50 billion, a rather intimateWhile the President is insisting that Congress will pass
group of about 50. (Reuters)the proposed bank tax, it is hardly a foregone
The tax is proposed to last 10 years and estimatedconclusion. Republicans, not to mention the financial
to generate about 90 billion for the government, theindustry, is opposing it. And just what will the bankers
majority of that from the ten largest banks. Thespend all those billions in bonus money on? According
question is who will really be paying? In all likelihoodto CNNMoney, at the top of the list is real estate.
the banks will use creative accounting to sidestep theBank execs will spend money on swanky New York
tax, as well as share the pain with bank customers inapartments and European vacation homes. Also on
higher fees and tighter rules.the banking bonus wish list is private school tuition,
The idea behind the tax is that the Obamaexpensive vacations, boats, cars and Botox. Yes,
administration hopes this fee will give banks andBotox. Apparently big time bankers need to look
other companies an incentive to whittle downwrinkle-free to stay competitive.